Feedback and comments welcome

Jump to: navigation, search

We welcome all feedback and comments on the guidelines under development.


Mackiwg (talk)16:57, 5 July 2009
  • "including a minimum of 30 calendar days for discussion" - should this match "minimum period of 15 calendar days" on the Workgroups Guidelines page?
KTucker (talk)10:13, 30 September 2009

Good catch, Kim! In the initiating a workgroup section the step following create a charter says:

5. Post to the main WikiEducator list providing a concise summary of the Workgroup and requesting community review and comment on the Workgroup charter, including a minimum of 30 calendar days for discussion with clearly stated deadline for comments. Collect the comments and suggestions in a section of the charter or corresponding talk page.

and then later in the formal constitution section the following is stated as a requirement:

3. A minimum period of 15 calendar days was provided from the date of the community announcement on the WikiEducator list before approvals of the charter by signed participants of the Workgroup.

I'd say one of these needs to change. I suggest changing the latter to be 30 calendar days.

Any other opinions?

ASnieckus (talk)13:04, 30 September 2009

In the "Formal constitution..." section, revised #3 (and #4) to be 30 calendar days for consistency with earlier procedure.

ASnieckus (talk)11:22, 24 October 2009