License compatibility: Example 2

From WikiEducator
Jump to: navigation, search



RTENOTITLE


Icon qmark.gif
Try your luck with this hand
  • Can these resources be aggregated and legally released as a derivative work?
    • Yes
      • Correct. Resources in the public domain and CC-BY licensed materials can be mixed with the GNU FDL.
    • No
      • Incorrect. These licenses are compatible -- public domain and CC-BY materials can be mixed with the GNU FDL.
  • Which of the following licenses could be used for the derivative work:
    • All rights reserved Copyright
      • Incorrect. The GNU FDL (a copyleft license) requires that derivative works are released under the same share-alike license.
    • CC-BY
      • Incorrect. This would be incompatible with the share-alike provisions of the GNU FDL.
    • Released under a public domain declaration
      • Incorrect.The CC-BY has an attribution requirement and attribution is not a legal requirement of resources in the public domain and the GNU FDL requires modifications to be released under the identical share-alike license.
    • GNU FDL
      • Correct The derivative work can be released under the GNU FDL as this would be in accordance with the share-alike provisions of the FDL.
    • BY-SA
      • Incorrect. While the BY-SA license has similar intentions and is "philosophically" aligned with the GNU FDL, the FDL requires that derivative works are released under the same license, and consequently equivalent share-alike licenses cannot be used.
    • BY-NC-ND
      • Incorrect. Adding more restrictions would not be in accordance with the GNU FDL.
    • BY-NC-SA
      • Incorrect. Adding the non-commercial restriction is not permitted by the GNU FDL, however the more substantive reason is that the GNU FDL requires modifications to be released under the identical license.



This is a remix inspired by the online version of David Wiley's OER remix game.