Prerequisite skills

Jump to: navigation, search

Hi Keith,

That's a valid observation. The challenge in designing the draft survey like this will be achieving consensus on what to include and what to exclude.

When putting the draft together -- I actually thought about distinguishing between writing, reading. speaking and listening skills, but then decided against it to keep the number of items down. That said -- it would only add three additional questions, so it wouldn't increase the load too much.

With particular reference to the multilingual learning context - -this info would be valuable.

I'm comfortable with increasing the number of questions when measured against the value of the data here. What do others think?

Mackiwg (talk)10:50, 6 July 2011

My vote is to keep it as communication. I think the skill type (i.e., reading, writing, listening, and speaking - along with many other nonverbal, socio-cultural-historical aspects) will depend in large part on the type of MOOC and the way in which the MOOC is delivered by the facilitators. A more specific skill-type analysis might be helpful as a course needs analysis, but again, since a large part of MOOCs that I've seen have been asynchronous (focusing mainly on reading, writing, and some listening skills), language learners have the advantage of recasting, revising, repeating, etc. that is not possible in a live (synchronous) class. But again, this will depend on how much of the MOOK is asynchronous versus synchronous and which skills learners are required to use.

Bnleez (talk)11:05, 6 July 2011

On the side of keeping the item as communication

I should add that this will facilitate comparison with Rita Kop's research on PLENK2010 -- if we introduce a material change, we loose the basis for comparison.

An extra thought to consider as we work towards consensus.

Mackiwg (talk)11:12, 6 July 2011

That's a biggy...if we are using it for comparison purposes, we really need to keep all question items the same. For better or for worse. :)

Bnleez (talk)11:27, 6 July 2011

Looks like rough consensus is to keep communication skills.

Mackiwg (talk)15:50, 7 July 2011