Determine whether the following resources can be re-mixed and legally released as a derivative work, then answer the questions below.
Try your luck with this hand
- Can these resources be combined and legally released as a derivative work?
- Yes
- Correct. Resources in the public domain and CC-BY licensed materials can be mixed with a BY-NC licence.
- No
- Incorrect. These licences are compatible. The public domain and CC-BY materials can be combined with the BY-NC materials.
- Which of the following licences could be used for the derivative work?
- All rights reserved Copyright
- Correct. Since CC BY-NC does not contain a copy-left or Share-alike condition, it can be re-licensed under 'all rights reserved' (ARR), since no further rights are gained of an ARR work. You would still not be able to use this commercially.
- CC BY
- Incorrect. The NC restriction on the photo means the derivative work could not be licensed as CC-BY.
- Released under a public domain declaration
- Incorrect. The attribution requirements of CC-BY and the NC restriction would not allow this.
- CC BY-NC
- Correct The derivative work can be released under the same conditions of the most restricted licence in the pack. There are, however, other alternatives as well.
- CC BY-NC-ND
- Correct. It is possible to release this combination under a more restrictive licence by adding the ND restriction. However, where possible, we recommend that re-mixers try to respect the intentions of the original creators, especially where no new or original materials have been added.
- CC BY-NC-SA
- Correct. It is possible to release this combination under a more restrictive licence by adding the SA restriction. However, where possible, we recommend that re-mixers try to respect the intentions of the original creators, especially where no new or original materials have been added.
- CC BY-SA
- Incorrect. The NC restriction of the photo means that the NC restriction must be included in the licence for the combined materials. The SA licence does allow commercial activity for value-added services, on condition that the derivative work is also released under a share alike licence.
This is a re-mix inspired by the online version of David Wiley's OER re-mix game.
